>Date: Thu, 20 Jul 1995 11:58:51 -0400 >From: jnarveso@watarts.UWaterloo.ca (Jan Narveson) >Subject: Book Abstract >Cc: Marilyn Friedman Thanks to Scott Arnold and Kurt Wickman for their book abstracts. I too have one to contribute: POLITICAL CORRECTNESS For and Against By Marilyn Friedman and Jan Narveson In Political Correctness: For and Against, two prominent philosophers engage each other in a forthright debate over some of the centrally disputed topics in the controversy now being waged on college campuses across the nation In her lead essay supporting "political correctness," Marilyn Friedman challenges the critical response to hate speech codes, disputes the supposed preeminence of the Western canon, and champions "deep multiculturalism" over a "shallow global diversity" approach. She also argues that a "politically correct" perspective need not abandon the concept of truth even while recognizing its political vulnerabilities, and she defends feminism and feminists against widespread distortion and caricature. Jan Narveson, in his lead essay criticizing "political correctness," argues that the kind of equality of person envisaged in "old-fashioned" or "classical" liberalism is the genuine article. Despite good intentions, he argues, "politically correct" policies will increase the amount of arbitrary power wielded over us by an essentially unthinking state, and this will be worse for everyone -- including the allegedly oppressed persons in whose interests these programs are advocated. Friedman and Narveson conclude the volume with direct replies to each other's positions. Contents: Preface: Codes, Canons, Correctness, and Feminism, Marilyn Friedman; Politics, Ethics and "Political Correctness", Jan Narveson; Reply to Narveson, Marilyn Friedman; Reply to Friedman, Jan Narveson. Marilyn Friedman is Associate Professor of Philosophy at Washington University in St. Louis, Missouri. Jan Narveson is Professor of Philosophy at the University of Waterloo In Ontario. Published by Rowman and Littlefield, December 1994 -- 160 pages ISBN 0-8476-7986-l $l8.95 (paper) ISBN 0-8476-7985-3 $56.50 (cloth) __________________________________________________________________________ Jan Narveson (Professor) Department of Philosophy, University of Waterloo; Waterloo, Ontario, Canada, N2L 3G1 (519) 888-4567-1-2780# (from touch-tone); or 885-1211, ext. 2780 (via switchboard); FAX (519) 746-3097 Home: (519) 886-1673 (answering machine) e-mail: jnarveso@watarts.UWaterloo.ca